The Fifth Avenue Flywheel
Bitcoin treasury companies aren’t just vaults holding coins - they’re compounding machines that can turn $1 into $2 of market value, week after week. Treating them like passive REITs misses the point.
13/8/25
Imagine a company called Empire Holdings. It owns ten gleaming, historic buildings on Fifth Avenue in New York City. The buildings are all empty - no tenants, no rent - but every year they quietly rise in value because Fifth Avenue real estate is scarce and the world’s wealthy will always want a piece of it.
The stock market loves Empire Holdings so much that its shares trade for twice the value of the buildings it owns. If you sold all the buildings at market prices and gave the cash to shareholders, they’d get only half of what their shares currently sell for.
Why? Because the market knows Empire has a special trick.
Whenever Empire wants, it can sell more stock to raise cash, and because the shares trade at such a high price, every $1 it raises from investors buys $2 worth of Fifth Avenue real estate in market value terms.
So, if Empire raises $200 million by selling new shares, they go out and buy another building. The moment they add it to their portfolio, the market still values the whole company at double its real estate value, so that new building is suddenly “worth” $400 million in market terms.
It’s like a magician’s act: turn $1 of cash into $2 of market value, over and over.
Next year, Fifth Avenue prices go up again. Empire issues a little more stock. Buys another building. The market instantly re-prices their whole portfolio higher.
Over time, they own more and more Fifth Avenue buildings without borrowing money or waiting decades for rent to trickle in.
Bitcoin Treasury Companies
Now swap out Fifth Avenue buildings for Bitcoin.
A Bitcoin treasury company is like Empire Holdings, except instead of skyscrapers, it owns Bitcoin, an asset with far more volatility but historically much higher appreciation than prime NYC real estate.
If the market values the company at 2x, 3x, or even 4x the Bitcoin it holds, it can use the same trick:
Raise capital at a premium
Buy more Bitcoin at a relative discount
Compound holdings faster than simply buying and holding
That ability to compound is why the market doesn’t just value it at the “bricks-and-mortar” price of its Bitcoin. The company itself - as a machine that keeps adding more Bitcoin below market value - has intrinsic worth as a going concern.
Where Traditional Analysts Get It Wrong
Here’s the catch: markets don’t value REITs at a premium to assets. In fact, many trade at a discount to Net Tangible Assets (NTA). Property developers, on the other hand, tend to trade at modest earnings multiples, often 5–10x.
Traditional market experts misread Bitcoin Treasury Companies because they view them like REITs - passive owners of assets that should trade near or below NAV.
In reality, they’re closer to developers: active operators, constantly raising capital and building their portfolio. Except instead of land and buildings, they’re accumulating the world’s best-performing asset - one that could compound 30–50% annually for the next decade. They’re also doing it with near-zero transaction friction and can repeat the process every week. Something you can’t do with property.
A compounding machine like that deserves a valuation far more than 1x the value of the assets on its balance sheet. What you’re buying isn’t just the Bitcoin it holds today, but the engine that can keep acquiring more at a discount, again and again. It’s the difference between owning a stack of bricks and owning the builder who can keep putting up skyscrapers at half the usual cost, right in the heart of one of the fastest-rising real estate markets on the planet.
Legacy market commentators are certain that Treasury Co’s should trade at the valuation of a slow-moving REIT, not a super-charged property developer. What they’re missing (for now) can be your advantage.
Want more like this? Subscribe to my Substack to get future ideas directly.